Monday, September 13, 2010

The US political system is the way it is because we wanted it this way.

Over the past two years I've learned that there are certain aspects of our culture, American culture, that lead us to have leaders who lie to us, a media that spends more time covering Britney Spears than the war in Afghanistan, and a public that is unengaged in the political process, myself included. Before I try to elaborate, who or what caused this? Are we the people to blame? Or is it the leaders and media? I think it was the leaders/media ("the man"), mostly because it is in our own interest to be engaged in the political process, so why would we start out not wanting to be involved unless someone else made us think that other things were more worthy of our attention?

This is going to be a rant, okay? Okay. Just a random list of things that I think have political implications.

1. People always want to hear the positives, never the negatives. I saw this so much on Committee. People were so concerned with phrasing things in a positive light that the necessary truths to be communicated were instead obfuscated. It's strange how people, when they hear something negative, immediately take a negative attitude towards the person speaking as well.

My point here is... when you only want to hear the good and not the bad, you're putting people in a position to lie to you. By lie I don't mean literally "I said something that is completely untrue." I mean more... misdirection. You don't have to say false things to lie. You just have to confuse the listener, to obscure the reality of what is happening, by focusing on another aspect.

I just feel like because people don't take well to the cold hard truth, it puts leaders in a position to candy-coat the truth, which leads to misinformation and confusion, excluding people from the political process because they don't understand what is truly happening.

You might say, but Raja... it's just human psychology... people like to hear good things more than bad things. My counter is that I think to be human is to try and overcome our base instincts. Yes we have them, yes we should follow them to some extent. But I think to be human is to attempt to unite emotion with intellect. Yes, we love to hear positives over negatives, but by this point we know at an intellectual level that hearing the truth requires both, even if at an emotional level we prefer one over the other.

2. People don't like reading long emails. Let's say I have a lot of information to communicate to you, and the only way to communicate to you and like 100 other people efficiently is via email. It interests me that people, even though they may be super passionate about something, somehow don't have the passion to read the information I need to convey for them to pursue their passion. It needs to have color and be readable in 3 seconds. Seriously? Is this what American media and consumerism has done to us? Not everything that you need is going to come in small soundbytes. Come on now, let's sit still and just read. I think this explains a lot of people's issues with textbooks too... reading and comprehending takes a LONG time. Why do that when you can watch a show and get an immediate, vicarious, sense of accomplishment and belonging.

I admit I'm guilty of this from time to time, but I try hard to read through every email, regardless of length.

I guess my point with this one is how can you think critically and have nuanced opinions if you're not willing to take the time to form them. Our environment is designed, intentionally I think, to distract us from developing our own opinions. Maybe it's a long stretch to connect reading emails to this but I do find it a little ridiculous the lengths that need to be taken to capture people's attention.

I can't help but connect these things to our political situation. If you say you want to go into politics, people say "get used to lying" or some shit. How sad is that? It speaks volumes about our political system, and our perception of it. We all know politicians lie to us and yet somehow we let it happen. Ultimately it's because they prey on our weaknesses, our fears, our laziness to search for the truth for ourselves. And even if they told us the truth and nothing but, we would eat them alive.

3. People always want to know how something can benefit them. What gain will they get out of this action? I mean I know people have to watch out for themselves, cause it's a tough world out there and all, but I think there's a fine line between making wise choices for yourself and doing something to help everyone else.

If everyone did that what kind of world would we live in? We don't initiate the change because we think that others wouldn't participate, but this is precisely the problem. If everyone bought into the concept, the system would work. I'm being probably super vague right now because I don't want to go too far off on a tangent... this idea will be for another post... "The Prisoner's Dilemma and Utopia" or some shit.

Anyway, it just irritates me when I see that people aren't willing to make sacrifices for something they supposedly care about. Like when you are on a leadership team yet somehow can't bother yourself to wake up early and flier so I don't have to do it by myself every morning. I'm not bitter, I'm just saying that it takes a mindset that I don't agree with to make those choices. And I think it really has to do with the benefit they think they get out of the activity. How much enjoyment, fulfillment, etc. Not everything worth doing has immediate rewards. Immediacy is a symptom of capitalism... when driven to pursue our self interest we forget how to protect our common interests. Tragedy of the commons and all that... except unlike Hardin, I actually think morality is the only solution.

Hmm that's it for now, I'm done ranting...as always, ideas that I need to explore further and find the right way to phrase... this post does not capture the essence of what I feel about these issues. But that's for another day.


1 comment:

  1. Wow, Raja. I just read your entire blog. I didn't know you were keeping one. I feel the same way about not being able to articulate my thoughts because I have not been practicing REALLY writing - other than formulaic political analysis of course. I really enjoyed reading this. I think about a lot of those issues as well. I'm sure a lot of people do. You can tell that you're a very intelligent person, reading this. I hope you figure everything out! I say, leap and the net will appear. Well, actually Jason Mraz says that, but I like it, so I'm stealing it. Mentorship really was life-changing wasn't it? At least in our minds... haha. We'll see about reality! It seems like SO MANY "emerging adults" want to reform education right now! Has it always seemed like this to every generation? Or is that new? Maybe it's new and they'll be a huge push once our generation gets in a position to do something. We can hope, right? Or maybe the world will just end in 2012. That'd make things easier. Love you Raja! I'm always here if you ever want to just call and babble about stuff, too. ;)

    ReplyDelete